Category Archives: Toro

Leaf by Oscar Maduro

I’ve been busy doing some blind reviews for Benjamin over at Cigar Jedi. He has a great site set up, and I was really honored when he asked if I would like to be a guest reviewer. You can find my reviews at cigarjedi.com along with reviews of other cigars that are hard to get in shops here in Montana. The first one here is a blind review of the Leaf by Oscar Maduro.

Leaf by Oscar

Leaf by Oscar

-Country – Honduras
-Wrapper – Nicaraguan Maduro
-Binder – Honduras
-Filler – Honduras
-Size – 6 x 50
-Price – around $10

Appearance, Pre-light
A brown wrapper the color of dark-roasted coffee beans covers this very firm cigar. There are a few prominent veins running the length of the cigar and a small amount of damage (perhaps from over-stretching the wrapper leaf) near the head. I get very little aroma off the wrapper or the foot, but what I can smell is a slight sweetness. After clipping the triple cap the cold draw has a woodsy quality to it and quite a bit of resistance.

First 3rd
The foot takes fire easily and the first draws are mildly sweet with a touch of brightness on the retrohale. After the first few puffs the sweetness vanishes and the cigar settles into some slight earthiness without much character. A bitter finish follows each draw that is not overwhelming, but makes me reach for my water more than usual. The burn is fairly even so far into the first third, with only mild scalloping. Towards the end of this third some pepper comes in on the retrohale accompanied by some wood notes. This is a welcome change and has me eager to see where this cigar is heading.

Good burn

Good burn

Second 3rd
The ash and burn line have stayed true up to the second third, and the woodsy/pepper flavors are still the main event. Smoke production is good despite the tight draw, and the strength is on the low side of medium. So far this has been a perfect example of a cigar that shows its flavor only during the retrohale, but the smoke is smooth (not creamy) and medium in body.
Well into this third, and things have (unfortunately) stayed the same. The only difference is the wood note has darkened into a distinct oakiness. When the ash finally fell it revealed a “pencil tip” of filler that is probably thickly bunched ligero. The finish is still bitter and turning a little ashy, and the strength has moved up a notch to a solid medium.

"pencil" tip

“pencil” tip

Last 3rd
The final third is staying true to the pepper/oak formula. Although I get a sense of a deepening of these flavors, almost to a bourbon-like tannic quality, but any hope I had of a change up has been whisked away. The nub is not hot and the smoke has remained consistent, but overall this has not been a very exciting cigar.

Takeaway
If it sounds like I didn’t find the Leaf by Oscar impressive, it’s because I didn’t. The wood notes were fine, and the pepper added a nice bit of “oomph” to the smoke, but overall this cigar was extremely one dimensional.
That said, it burned great and I only had to touch up the wrapper once. I could see myself smoking this while fishing or at a BBQ with friends, but for a nice, sit-down smoke I would reach for something different. If woodiness is what you’re looking for in a cigar, then go for it. I wouldn’t buy this cigar, but I would gladly smoke it if someone gifted it to me.

Flavor – Medium-Full
Strength – Medium
Body – Medium
Construction – Good

Rating

2.5 out of 5 Not bad, just not a sit-down-and-enjoy kind of cigar.
.
You can find my rating system here.

Wicked Indie

Wicked Indie

Wicked Indie

This cigar is from the East India Company, a sister company to Gurkha Cigars. Both are owned by Beach Cigar Group.

-Wrapper – Nicaraguan Habano
-Binder – Nicaraguan
-Filler – 3 year aged Nicaraguan
-Size – Toro 6 x 54
-Price – $5, $6.09 in Bozeman, MT

Appearance, Pre-light
This cigar has a firm bunch up and down its length. The wrapper is milk-chocolate brown with a few veins and has a dry, sandpaper feel to it. It is a little bumpy (not toothy, bumpy) and puts off a hay aroma from the foot.

First Third

First Third


First 3rd
The first few puffs on the Wicked Indie bring a subtle flavor of dry spices. There is a touch of sweetness towards the roof of my mouth and in the retro-hale that reminds me of citrus. A bit of bitterness is also present, and it helps define the citrus as having a grapefruit quality. The smoke has a dusty texture that I find in some other cigars, and that mouthfeel is one I find very enjoyable when done correctly. Sometimes it can really dry my palate out or give the smoke a gritty feel, but this cigar is just fine. The finish is pleasantly short and leaves no weird taste behind. After the first inch or so, some black pepper appears in the retro-hale.

Second 3rd
The pepper moves into the background at the start of the second third. The little bit of sweetness has abated quite a bit, and the spices have morphed into the baking-spice variety. So far the burn has been crooked and high maintenance, and the ash has been a light, dirty grey. At times the flavor disappears altogether for a few minutes, but the smoke output remains good during those times. Overall the Wicked Indie has remained fairly constant, besides some minor changes in the spice and sweetness. One nice thing is that occasionally I get a picture-perfect “Nicaraguan” sweet spice. The downside is this: that seems to be a happy coincidence as I’ve only tasted those that flavor twice in this first half.

Second Half

Second Half

Last 3rd
There’s not much of a change in the last third. The smoke output is still good, but the flavors are getting tainted by a hot, ashy characteristic. During this half there have been periods of a good burn line, but overall it has needed a lot of touch ups. About an inch and a half from the end I called it quits. If not for reviewing this cigar, I would have put it down earlier.

Takeaway
I would call this a good cigar, but that’s as far as it goes. There are some decent flavors to be found, and the price is good for a toro, but I would be willing to pay a little more for a better experience.

Not Bad...

Not Bad…

Flavor – Medium-minus
Strength – Mild-Medium
Body – Medium
Construction – Okay

Rating
I wouldn’t call attention to this stick if a fellow cigar nerd was looking for a new smoke, but I would recommend it to a novice. These would make mooching friends very happy, but cigar enthusiasts can find better sticks elsewhere. That said, the price makes this a pretty tempting offer.

2.75 out of 5